The following e-mail was recently posted to the Union of American Physicians and Dentists (UAPD) listserve.
Editorial Note: The meeting
described below occurred just minutes after a
letter was delivered to Mayor Gavin Newsom requesting a meeting
between the Medical Staff at LHH and the Mayor. The meeting
with Dr. Katz was not an outcome of the letter to the Mayor, nor
was it a substitute for the doctor's requested meeting with the
Mayor. Editorial explanatory material is noted in green
Subject: Laguna Honda: Homeless Facility, not
a SNF under Dr. Katz?
Date: Wed, 20 Oct 2004 08:55:13 -0700
To: SF UAPD Listserve <UAPD-SF@yahoogroups.com>
The Vision and Leadership of Dr. Mitchell Katz/Laguna Honda-forwarded by reliable Laguna Honda Medical Staff [Member] is this what San Franciscans voted for?
Third hand reports related to todays LHH Executive Committee Meeting are for your consideration not action. Please verify these indirect and hearsay interpretations with someone who attended the meeting.
Dr. Mitchell Katz introduced one John Kanaley as the soon to be LHH CEO to the Hospital Executive Committee today. Dr. Katz was variously described as being under pressure, unusually nervous, etc. However, he delivered a 45 minute oration which included his vision for LHH [as being] a social rehabilitation facility for the homeless poor. [Editors Note: The Health Commission is now putting spin control to work, denying that Dr. Katz used these words. At the October 28 LHH Joint Conference Committee, one of the Health Commissioners noted that Dr. Katz had simply "used a poor choice of words," but a source who witnessed the meeting notes these were the words Katz used before the Hospital Executive Committee.] Future CEO Canaley, reportedly an associate-COO at SFGH, with some operations experience at Kaiser Fresno and no long-term care experience, took notes for the duration. Interestingly, Mr. Canaley had previously stated he would not come to LHH while Larry Funk was still CEO, out of respect for Larry Funk.
The Health Director opined at length on the deficiencies he perceived at LHH in regards to 3 patients with challenging behaviors and complex psycho-social needs. His more pointed critique was directed at LHH Social Work staff, although my sources indicate that Dr. Mitchell Katz's understanding and knowledge of the patients and the services they received was surprisingly simplistic, slanted and inaccurate. He was not openly challenged on his clinical misconceptions at the meeting, apparently. Dr. Mitchell Katz also took the opportunity to magnify the modest contributions made by SFGH staff when one of those patients was temporarily transferred there.
Toward the end of the meeting Dr. Mitchell
Katz apparently exhibited powerful leadership by throwing out
the question to the effect of: Will you be able to get your
staff behind what we are trying to do in this new model of care?
At this time, I have no information about the response to this query.
Top Return to Public Testimony & Public Commentary
Copyright (c) 2004 by Committee to Save LHH. All rights reserved. This work may not be reposted anywhere on the Web, or reprinted in any print media, without express written permission. E-mail the Committee to Save LHH.